Αναλογιστική Μελέτη ΓεΣΥ 2024–2033
Health Insurance Organisation (HIO / ΟΑΥ) · First seen 19 Oct 2026 · Report · Greek
The text was read from a scanned document (OCR).
Summary
Written by AI from the linked sources (EU AI Act 2024/1689, Art. 50). Each sentence links to its source.
This ILO report to the Health Insurance Organization (HIO) presents the fourth actuarial valuation of Cyprus's General Healthcare System (GHS) as of 31 December 2023, projecting its financial situation for 2024–2033. It covers GHS income and expenditure, demographic and labour market assumptions, claims experience, reconciliation with the previous valuation, sensitivity tests, and conclusions with an actuarial opinion. The excerpt provided shows mainly copyright notices, foreword and table of contents; the full financial results are not included in the text supplied. Original
GeSYBudgetStatisticsWorkforceMedicinesPublic health
Figures taken from this document
–
Numbers found in the text
Each figure is read twice, separately, and kept only when both readings agree and the number appears word for word in the text.
| Indicator | Reading | Value | In the text | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Indicator | Reading | 932 source | found word for word | 5 Z-Drugs 138 117 42 371 705 307 Z-Consumables 200 814 84 105 598 419 Z-Procedures & fixed fee 238 061 60 882 665 256 2024 DRGs 286 390 553 376 201 1 932 Z-Drugs 181 637 54 826 082 302 Z-Consumables 230 020 98 456 612 428 Z-Procedures &… |
| Indicator | Reading | 900 source | found word for word | 9 618 18 475 38 093 4-7 20 237 19 158 39 395 20 683 19 565 40 248 8-14 35 081 32 968 68 049 36 106 33 802 69 908 15-17 14 290 13 405 27 695 14 599 13 900 28 499 18-25 40 696 39 916 80 612 42 427 41 084 83 511 26-30 34 592 34 622 69 214 35… |
| Indicator | Reading | 70 source | found word for word | 61 2. The ILO/HEALTH modelling framework ............................................................................................................ 70 3. Scheme-specific data and assumptions… |
| Indicator | Reading | 46 source | found word for word | ................ 45 7.2. Changes to key assumptions: 2023 versus 2022 actuarial valuations .......................................................... 46 7.3. Reconciliation of the reserve between 2023 and 2022 actuarial valuations… |
| Indicator | Reading | 600 000 source | found word for word | the projection period, it is expected to be in the range of 2.8 to 3.0 per cent, averaging to 2.9 per cent. - 100 000 200 000 300 000 400 000 500 000 600 000 700 000 800 000 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 Population aged… |
| Indicator | Reading | 20 000 source | found word for word | 14 66 20 100 31 2030 14 66 20 100 31 2031 14 66 20 100 31 2032 14 65 21 100 32 2033 14 65 21 100 32 -12 000 -8 000 -4 000 - 4 000 8 000 12 000 16 000 20 000 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 2017 2019 2021 2023 Net… |
| Indicator | Reading | 120 source | found word for word | % 66% 66% 65% 65% 18% 19% 19% 19% 20% 20% 20% 20% 21% 21% 3,6 3,5 3,4 3,4 3,3 3,3 3,2 3,2 3,2 3,1 0,0 1,0 2,0 3,0 4,0 5,0 6,0 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 Old-age support ratio Population… |
| Indicator | Reading | 80 source | found word for word | ...... 79 A3.5. Sample mortality rates applied to the insured population ............................................................................ 80 A3.6. Rates of entry into invalidity… |
| Indicator | Reading | 11 source | found word for word | .... 10 3.3. Indicators to assess financial sustainability .......................................................................................... 11 4. Demographic, economic and labour market framework… |
| Indicator | Reading | 15 source | found word for word | ................................................................. 7 4.1. Projection of the percentage distribution of population by age groups (0-14, 15-64 and 65+), 2024-2033… |
| Indicator | Reading | 3 500 source | found word for word | degree of uncertainty: 0,42 0,40 0,39 0,37 0,36 0,35 0,35 0,35 0,35 0,35 0,30 0,32 0,34 0,36 0,38 0,40 0,42 0,44 - 500 1 000 1 500 2 000 2 500 3 000 3 500 4 000 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 Reserve ratio Amounts in… |
Text of the document
The text is shortened here. The full text is available from the API.
ILO/TF/Cyprus/R.29 CYPRUS Fourth Report to the Health Insurance Organization Actuarial valuation of the General Healthcare System as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 Copyright © International Labour Organization 2026 This is an open access work distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Users can reuse, share, adapt and build upon the original work, as detailed in the License. The ILO must be clearly credited as the owner of the original work. The use of the emblem of the ILO is not permitted in connection with users’ work. Attribution – The work must be cited as follows: Report to the Health Insurance Organization: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033. Translations – In case of a translation of this work, the following disclaimer must be added along with the attribution: This translation was not created by the International Labour Organization (ILO) and should not be considered an official ILO translation. The ILO is not responsible for the content or accuracy of this translation. Adaptations – In case of an adaptation of this work, the following disclaimer must be added along with the attribution: This is an adaptation of an original work by the International Labour Organization (ILO). Responsibility for the views and opinions expressed in the adaptation rests solely with the author or authors of the adaptation and are not endorsed by the ILO. This CC license does not apply to non-ILO copyright materials included in this publication. If the material is attributed to a third party, the user of such material is solely responsible for clearing the rights with the right holder. Any dispute arising under this license that cannot be settled amicably shall be referred to arbitration in accordance with the Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL). The parties shall be bound by any arbitration award rendered as a result of such arbitration as the final adjudication of such a dispute. Queries on rights and licensing should be addressed to the ILO Publishing Unit (Rights and Licensing) at rights@ilo.org. Information on ILO publications and digital products can be found at: www.ilo.org/publns. The designations employed in ILO publications and databases, which are in conformity with United Nations practice, and the presentation of material therein do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the ILO concerning the legal status of any country, area or territory or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. The opinions and views expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the opinions, views or policies of the ILO. Reference to names of firms and commercial products and processes does not imply their endorsement by the ILO, and any failure to mention a particular firm, commercial product or process is not a sign of disapproval. Printed in Switzerland Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 iii Foreword The present report has been prepared in the framework of the Trust-in-Fund project between the Health Insurance Organization (HIO) and the International Labour Organization, entitled “Actuarial Support Services to the Health Insurance Organisation” (CYP/25/02/CYP). The project aims at conducting actuarial valuation studies for assessing the financial sustainability of the Healthcare Insurance Fund (GHS Fund), using the ILO modelling approach designed for health insurance schemes, which is built on the principles of social security that underlie the ILO Conventions. This report, which has been carried out as of 31 December 2023 in compliance with relevant international actuarial standards, presents the financial results of the fourth actuarial valuation of the GHS since its inception in June 2019, covering the period from 2024 to 2033. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 v Contents Page Foreword .................................................................................................................................................................. iii Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................................................ xi Executive summary ................................................................................................................................................ xiii Abbreviations and acronyms ................................................................................................................................ xvii 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................................. 1 1.1. Objectives of the actuarial valuation ..................................................................................................... 1 1.2. Scope of the report .................................................................................................................................. 2 2. Description of the General Healthcare System provisions ................................................................... 3 2.1. Covered population.................................................................................................................................. 3 2.2. Healthcare services under GHS .............................................................................................................. 3 2.3. Financing approach.................................................................................................................................. 4 2.4. Source of funding ..................................................................................................................................... 4 2.5. Reimbursement methods ....................................................................................................................... 4 3. Projection methodologies .......................................................................................................................... 6 3.1. Methodology for modelling GHS income .............................................................................................. 7 3.2. Methodology for modelling the GHS expenditure .............................................................................. 10 3.3. Indicators to assess financial sustainability .......................................................................................... 11 4. Demographic, economic and labour market framework ..................................................................... 13 4.1. Demographic framework ........................................................................................................................ 13 4.2. Economic and Labour market framework ............................................................................................ 17 5. General Healthcare System: Experience and assumptions .................................................................. 22 5.1. Financial experience ................................................................................................................................ 22 5.2. Coverage experience ............................................................................................................................... 23 5.3. Claims experience and projection assumptions .................................................................................. 25 5.4. Administrative expenditure projection assumption ............................................................................ 32 6. General Healthcare System: Base scenario projection results ............................................................ 33 6.1. Demographic projections ........................................................................................................................ 33 6.2. Financial projections ................................................................................................................................ 36 7. Reconciliation with the previous valuation ............................................................................................ 44 7.1. Introduction .............................................................................................................................................. 44 7.2. Amendments to the legislation .............................................................................................................. 44 7.3. Methodological improvements to the projection model .................................................................... 44 7.4. Experience update, 2022–23 ................................................................................................................... 44 7.5. Changes in assumptions ......................................................................................................................... 45 7.6. Reconciliation results ............................................................................................................................... 47 Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 vi Page 8. Sensitivity scenarios and tests .................................................................................................................. 49 8.1. Sensitivity scenarios ................................................................................................................................. 51 8.2. Sensitivity tests ......................................................................................................................................... 53 8.3. Test results ................................................................................................................................................ 54 9. Conclusions and recommendations ......................................................................................................... 58 10. Actuarial opinion ......................................................................................................................................... 60 Annexes 1. Design features of the GHS ................................................................................................................................ 61 2. The ILO/HEALTH modelling framework ............................................................................................................ 70 3. Scheme-specific data and assumptions ............................................................................................................ 77 4. Claims experience analysis and assumptions .................................................................................................. 86 List of tables in the annexes A1.1. Healthcare services covered by the GHS, by implementation date .............................................................. 62 A1.2. Contribution rates for each category of contributors during the first phase and full implementation phase ........................................................................................................................................ 63 A1.3. Co-payments applied by healthcare service providers ................................................................................... 64 A1.4. Annual co-payments cap by beneficiary category ........................................................................................... 65 A1.5. Age groups and capitation rates ........................................................................................................................ 67 A3.1. Active insured persons, 2023 .............................................................................................................................. 77 A3.2. Inactive insured persons, 2023 .......................................................................................................................... 78 A3.3. Average annual insurable earnings of active contributors, 2023.................................................................. 78 A3.4. Registered beneficiaries, 2023–24 ..................................................................................................................... 79 A3.5. Sample mortality rates applied to the insured population ............................................................................ 80 A3.6. Rates of entry into invalidity ............................................................................................................................... 80 A3.7. Assumptions on the family structure, for male insured persons .................................................................. 81 A3.8. Assumptions on the family structure, for female insured persons .............................................................. 82 A3.9. Statutory pensions (amounts in euros where applicable) .............................................................................. 82 A3.10. Invalidity pensions (amounts in euros where applicable) .............................................................................. 83 A3.11. Widows’/widowers’ pensions (amounts in euros where applicable) ............................................................. 83 A3.12. Orphans’ pensions (amounts in euros where applicable) .............................................................................. 84 A3.13. GHS scheme specific assumptions .................................................................................................................... 85 A4.1. Inpatient utilization rates, by gender, 2022–2024 ........................................................................................... 87 A4.2. Inpatient average cost per invoice, by gender, 2022–2024 ........................................................................... 87 A4.3. Outpatient utilization rates, by category and by gender, 2022–2024 ........................................................... 88 A4.4. Outpatient average cost per invoice, by category and by gender, 2022–2024 .......................................... 89 Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 vii Page A4.5. Laboratory utilization rates, by category, 2022–2024 ..................................................................................... 90 A4.6. Laboratories, average cost per invoice, by category, 2022–2024 .................................................................. 90 A4.7. Outpatient care pharmacy utilization rates, 2022–2024 ................................................................................. 91 A4.8. Outpatient care pharmaceuticals, weighted average cost per invoice, 2022–24 ........................................ 91 A4.9. Inpatient DRGs, quarterly utilization rate assumption, by age group and gender, 2024–2033 ............... 92 A4.10. Inpatient Z consumables, quarterly utilization rate assumption, by age group and gender, 2024–2033 ............................................................................................................................................................. 92 A4.11. Inpatient Z drugs, quarterly utilization rate assumption, by age group and gender, 2024–2033............ 93 A4.12. Inpatient Z procedures and fixed fee items, quarterly utilization rate assumption, by age group and gender, 2024–2033 ....................................................................................................................................... 94 A4.13. Outpatient specialists, quarterly utilization rate assumption, by age group and gender, 2024–2033 .... 94 A4.14. Allied health professionals, quarterly utilization rate assumption, by age group and gender, 2024–2033 ............................................................................................................................................................. 95 A4.15. Dentists, quarterly utilization rate assumption, by age group and gender, 2024–2033 ............................ 96 A4.16. Nurses and midwives, quarterly utilization rate assumption, by age group and gender, 2024–2033 .... 96 A4.17. Assumptions of laboratory monthly utilization rate and average number of points per invoice, by test category, 2024–2033 ............................................................................................................................... 97 A4.18. Pharmacies and pharmaceuticals for outpatient care, monthly utilization rates and other projection assumptions, 2024–2033 ..................................................................................................................................... 97 A4.19. Personal doctors’ current capitation reimbursement annual rates .............................................................. 98 A4.20. A&E departments, private hospitals, assumptions of quarterly utilization rate and average number of points per invoice, 2024–2033 ....................................................................................................................... 98 A4.21. A&E departments of public hospitals, and ambulances, annual fixed cost ................................................. 98 A4.22. Rehabilitation and palliative care, assumption of annual cost, for the years 2024–2033 .......................... 99 List of tables ES.1. Projected financial situation of GHS, 2024–2033 ............................................................................................. xiii 2.1. Healthcare services covered by GHS by implementation date ...................................................................... 3 3.1. Legislated contribution rates ............................................................................................................................. 7 4.1. Projection of the percentage distribution of population by age groups (0–14, 15–64 and 65+), 2024–2033 ............................................................................................................................................................. 16 4.2. Annual growth of GDP, productivity and employment, 2024–2033 .............................................................. 18 4.3. Assumptions of labour force participation, employment and unemployment rates, 2024–2033 ............ 19 4.4. Assumptions of inflation rate, real and nominal increase of average wage, 2024–2033 .......................... 21 5.1. Financial statements, 2022–23 ........................................................................................................................... 22 5.2. Reconciliation of financial statements with the data received, 2022–23 ...................................................... 23 5.3. Financial Indicators, 2022–23 ............................................................................................................................. 23 5.4. Active contributors to the GHS, 2022–23 .......................................................................................................... 24 Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 viii Page 5.5. Registered beneficiaries in the GHS, 2019–2024 ............................................................................................. 24 5.6. Claims experience, inpatients, 2021–2024 ....................................................................................................... 26 5.7. Claims experience, outpatients, 2021–2024 ..................................................................................................... 27 5.8. Claims experience, laboratories, 2021–2024 .................................................................................................... 27 5.9. Claims experience, pharmacies and pharmaceuticals for outpatient care, 2021–2024 ............................. 28 5.10. Historical medical inflation, by healthcare category, 2012–2024 .................................................................. 28 5.11. Medical inflation assumption, by category, 2026–2033 .................................................................................. 29 5.12. Inpatient DRGs, quarterly utilization rate assumption, by age group and gender, 2024–2033 ............... 30 5.13. Outpatient specialists, quarterly utilization rate assumption, by age group and gender, 2024–2033 .... 30 5.14. Pharmacies and pharmaceuticals for outpatient care, monthly utilization rates other projection assumptions, 2024–2033 ..................................................................................................................................... 31 6.1. Projection of GHS contributing population, by category, 2024–2033 ........................................................... 34 6.2. Projection of year-end GHS registered beneficiaries, by gender, 2024–2033 ............................................. 35 6.3. Projection of year-end GHS registered beneficiaries, by age group, 2024–2033 ........................................ 35 6.4. Projection of employee contributory earnings and other income sources, 2024–2033 ............................ 36 6.5. Projection of GHS income, by category, 2024–2033 ........................................................................................ 37 6.6. Projection of GHS contribution income, by income source, 2024–2033 ...................................................... 37 6.7. Projection of other income, 2024–2033 ............................................................................................................ 38 6.8. Projection of GHS benefit expenditure, by healthcare category, 2024–2033 .............................................. 38 6.9. Projection of inpatient benefits expenditure, by service type, 2024–2033 .................................................. 40 6.10. Projection of benefits expenditure, outpatient pharmacies and pharmaceuticals for outpatient and inpatient care, by service, 2024–2033 ........................................................................................................ 41 6.11. Projection of benefits expenditure, dentists, allied health professionals and nurses & midwives, by category, 2024–2033....................................................................................................................................... 41 6.12. Projection of administrative expenses, by category, 2024–2033 .................................................................. 42 6.13. Projected financial situation of GHS, 2024–2033 ............................................................................................. 42 7.1. Changes in GHS reserves, 2022–23 ................................................................................................................... 45 7.2. Changes to key assumptions: 2023 versus 2022 actuarial valuations .......................................................... 46 7.3. Reconciliation of the reserve between 2023 and 2022 actuarial valuations ................................................ 48 7.4. Reconciliation of the reserve ratio between 2023 and 2022 actuarial valuations ....................................... 48 8.1. Sensitivity scenario assumptions ....................................................................................................................... 50 8.2. Sensitivity test assumptions ............................................................................................................................... 51 8.3. Results of sensitivity scenarios ........................................................................................................................... 55 8.4. Results of sensitivity tests ................................................................................................................................... 56 Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 ix Page List of figures ES.1. Total income, total expenditure and reserve ratio of the GHS, 2024–2033 ................................................. xiv 3.1. Actuarial methodological modelling framework ..................................................................................... 6 3.2. Methodology: GHS contribution income from GSIS income sources ...................................................... 8 3.3. Methodology regarding GHS income from GSIS contributing population .............................................. 8 3.4. Methodology regarding GHS income from the GSIS pensioner population ........................................... 9 4.1. Historical life expectancies at birth, 1978–2023 ...................................................................................... 14 4.2. Historical total fertility rates, 1990–2023 ................................................................................................. 15 4.3. Historical net migration flows, 1995–2023 .............................................................................................. 16 4.4. Projected population percentage distribution and old-age support ratio, 2024–2033 ........................... 17 4.5. Projected labour force participation rates, 2024–2033 ........................................................................... 19 4.6. Evolution of the distribution of population aged 15–64, by labour force status, 2024–2033 .................... 20 5.1. Evolution of the number of registered beneficiaries, 2019–2024 ................................................................. 25 6.1. Projection of GHS contributing population by category, 2024–2033 ............................................................ 34 6.2. Projection of year-end GHS registered beneficiaries, by age group, 2024–2033 ........................................ 36 6.3. Breakdown of GHS benefits expenditure, by healthcare category, 2024 .................................................... 39 6.4. Breakdown of GHS benefits expenditure, by healthcare category, 2028 .................................................... 39 6.5. Breakdown of GHS benefits expenditure, by healthcare category, 2033 .................................................... 40 6.6. Total income, total expenditure and reserve ratio of the GHS, 2024–2033 ................................................. 43 A2.1. Overview of the modelling framework (building blocks) ................................................................................ 71 A2.2. Overview of the relationships between models, scenarios, schemes and population groups ................ 74 A2.3. Overview of the calculation flow (a simplified flow) ................................................................................ 74 A4.1. Evolution of inpatient utilization rates, by age group, males, 2023–24 ................................................... 87 A4.2. Evolution of inpatient utilization rates, by age group, females, 2023–24 ................................................ 88 A4.3. Evolution of outpatient utilization rates, by age group, males, 2023–24 ................................................ 89 A4.4. Evolution of outpatient utilization rates, by age group, females, 2023–24 ................................................. 90 Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 xi Acknowledgements The ILO designated the Actuarial Service Unit (ASU) of the Universal Social Protection Department (SOCPRO) to oversee the conduct of the present actuarial valuation of the GHS Fund. Mr Costas Stavrakis, FIA, FCAA, senior social security actuary, undertook this work with the assistance of Mr Andreas Andreou, actuarial modelling expert. Mr André Picard, FSA, FCIA, the Head of SOC/ASU, supervised the project, provided technical inputs to the present actuarial valuation, as well as assumed overall technical responsibility. The ILO project team worked in close collaboration with Mr Angelos Tropis, the HIO Director of the Finance Directorate and the HIO project coordinator for the gathering of data and discussions on various aspects of the actuarial valuation. In addition to Mr Tropis, the ILO team is grateful to the HIO project team of the Finance Directorate as well as the various HIO subject-matter experts on the healthcare services covered under the GHS, who provided invaluable assistance throughout this project. The ILO extends its gratitude to the executive directors of the HIO for their fruitful collaboration and contribution throughout the project. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 xiii Executive summary This report presents the results of the actuarial valuation of the GHS of the Republic of Cyprus as of 31 December 2023. Projections have been made over a period of ten years, that is until 31 December 2033, as GHS provides short-term benefits highly influenced by the expansion of healthcare services and continuing advances in medical technology. The projection period is in line with actuarial practice for this kind of scheme. The historical data provided by HIO for the GHS income and expenditure projection have been sufficient and reliable. Nonetheless, the present actuarial valuation is subject to a high degree of uncertainty due to relatively insufficient historical series of GHS expenditure data, which constrains the development of robust and stable actuarial assumptions across several key areas. Subsequent actuarial valuations are expected for continuous monitoring of the financial evolution of the GHS and to hold a higher degree of certainty as they will gradually be based on longer series of historical data. Base scenario Financial projections as shown in table ES.1, indicates that the GHS Fund is financially sustainable over the period 2024–2033 under the current GHS provisions, including the legislated schedule of contribution rates. The above projections assume no policy change in terms of adding new GHS healthcare services other than those which had been anticipated to be introduced at the time of writing this report. Therefore, considering the reserve, 1 contribution rates are assessed to be appropriate to sustain the scheme financially in the short term and medium term and thus ensuring the maintenance of a constantly positive reserve. Table ES.1. Projected financial situation of GHS, 2024–2033 (in millions of euros) Year 2024 1 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 Reserve (start of year) 594 709 759 781 791 797 808 824 850 882 Total GHS income 1 832 1 993 2 081 2 165 2 243 2 326 2 411 2 503 2 594 2 691 Total GHS benefits expenditure 1 699 1 921 2 028 2 121 2 199 2 279 2 358 2 440 2 524 2 610 Total other income 7 10 12 13 13 15 15 16 16 17 Total administrative expenses 25 32 43 47 51 51 52 53 54 55 Surplus/Deficit 115 50 22 10 6 11 16 26 32 43 Reserve (end of year) 709 759 781 791 797 808 824 850 882 925 Reserve ratio 2 0.42 0.40 0.39 0.37 0.36 0.35 0.35 0.35 0.35 0.35 Administrative expense ratio 3 (%) 1.4 1.6 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.2 2.2 2.1 2.1 2.0 Total GHS benefits expenditure/ Nominal GDP (%) 5.1 5.5 5.5 5.5 5.5 5.5 5.4 5.4 5.4 5.4 1 The estimated financial figures for 2024 are derived from actual experience data. 2 Reserve ratio refers to the level of reserve at the end of one year to the level of GHS expenditure for the same year. For example, a reserve ratio of 8.3% (one twelfth) indicates that the level of reserve covers one month’s expenditure. 3 Administrative expense ratio refers to the ratio of the level of administrative expenses in any year to the total GHS income amount of the same year. ______ 1 For the purposes of the present report, reserve refers to the GHS Fund accumulated surplus. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 xiv Figure ES.1 shows graphically the evolution of total income, total expenditure and reserve ratio of the GHS for 2024–2033. Figure ES.1. Total income, total expenditure and reserve ratio of the GHS, 2024–2033 (in million of euros) It follows from table ES.1 and figure ES.1 that the projected reserve ratio remains positive throughout the projection period indicating the sufficiency of the annual GHS income to cover the annual GHS expenditure. Nevertheless, over the period 2024–2029, there is a downward trend in the reserve ratio. From 2029 to 2033, the reserve ratio is projected to remain stable at an adequate level, above four months’ expenditure, reflecting broadly aligned growth rates between total GHS revenues and expenditures. Sensitivity scenarios and tests Since all projections have a degree of uncertainty, a variety of sensitivity scenarios and tests were carried out in order to measure the sensitivity of the projected financial position of the GHS Fund to future changes in the demographic and economic environments. Three sensitivity scenarios were performed on the results of the actuarial valuation to examine their sensitivity to changes in the following set of assumptions or measures: o economic adverse scenario, resulting to lower net migration, lower GDP growth rates, lower nominal wage increases, lower employment growth rates and lower labour-force participation rates from 2025 onwards, when compared to base scenario; and o introduction of new healthcare services, which are not currently covered by the GHS legislation. o GHS financial governance improvement: Activation of GHS institutional measures relating to its financial governance, which aim towards benefit cost containment, in accordance with the regulatory framework of the GHS. In addition, individual sensitivity tests were performed on the results of the actuarial valuation to assess their sensitivity to changes, either more or less favourable for the GHS, in the following four key GHS variables which are subject to a relatively high degree of uncertainty: 0,42 0,40 0,39 0,37 0,36 0,35 0,35 0,35 0,35 0,35 0,30 0,32 0,34 0,36 0,38 0,40 0,42 0,44 - 500 1 000 1 500 2 000 2 500 3 000 3 500 4 000 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 Reserve ratio Amounts in million € Total Income Total Expenditure Reserve Ratio Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 xv o cost resulting from the introduction of new/innovative drugs; o medical inflation: progressive growth to a higher or a lower level by 0.5 per cent over the projection period; o increase or decrease in utilization rates (all services); and o increase or decrease in inpatient utilization rates. The above sensitivity scenarios and tests show that, even though the projected financial status of the GHS Fund is sensitive to the above measures and assumptions, the reserve remains constantly positive over the next decade, until 2033, securing the viability of the GHS Fund. Nevertheless, certain sensitivity scenarios and tests have greater financial impact than others, resulting to, by the end of 2033: ● Higher reserve covering more than five months’ expenditure – namely the scenario for GHS financial governance improvement and the sensitivity tests of progressive decrease of medical inflation, decrease in utilization rates and decrease in the inpatient utilization rates. ● Lower reserve level covering between two and a half, and three months’ expenditure – namely the economic adverse scenario and the sensitivity test of increase in the inpatient utilization rates. ● Lower reserve covering slightly above two months’ expenditure – sensitivity test of increase in utilization rates. Given the high degree of uncertainty associated with the projected financial results of the present actuarial valuation, as illustrated by sensitivity analyses, it is vital that the financial position of the GHS Fund is monitored closely and on a regular basis, so that, where necessary, corrective measures are taken in a timely manner. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 xvii Abbreviations and acronyms BE benefits expenditure CI contribution income CR contribution rate CPI consumer price index DRG Diagnosis Related Group GDP gross domestic product GEPS Government Employees Pension Scheme GHS General Healthcare System GSIS General Social Insurance Scheme HIO Health Insurance Organization FFS Fee for Service IAA International Actuarial Association ILO International Labour Office/Organization ISSA International Social Security Association PD personal doctor SHSO organization managing public hospitals SPS Social Pension Scheme GHS Fund Healthcare Insurance Fund Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 1 1. Introduction The present actuarial valuation report of the Cyprus General Healthcare System (GHS) has been carried out in compliance with the provisions of Part II, Article 4(2)(e) of the General Healthcare System Law of 2001 (N.89(I)/2001), which stipulates that the HIO has the authority to conduct actuarial valuations of the GHS on an annual basis. This report presents the financial situation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023 and the financial results of an ILO actuarial assessment for measuring the financial sustainability of the GHS up to 2033. The present actuarial valuation represents the fourth actuarial valuation of the GHS since its inception in June 2019. Given the recent implementation of the GHS as of 1 June 2019 and 2020 for Phase I and Phase II respectively, the present actuarial valuation is subject to a high degree of uncertainty due to the relatively insufficient historical series of data, which constrains the development of robust and stable actuarial assumptions across several key areas. Therefore, a number of sensitivity scenarios and tests are undertaken in Chapter 8 of this report in order to evaluate the sensitivity of results under different evolution paths of key demographic, economic and GHS-specific assumptions. Continuous monitoring of the financial evolution of the GHS is paramount in this context, as well as the reconciliation of results with subsequent actuarial valuations. In particular, reconciliation of results facilitates the evaluation of the soundness and reasonableness of the actuarial assumptions and the necessary adjustments during future valuations. 1.1. Objectives of the actuarial valuation The main objective of the present actuarial valuation is to evaluate the financial situation of the GHS in the short and medium term, within the framework of the principles of social security that underlie the ILO Conventions. In particular, the present report aims to provide visibility on the financial sustainability of the GHS by reviewing the financial condition of GHS Fund in relation to its obligations arising from the implementation of the General Healthcare System Law of 2001. The main aims are to: o review the current and projected financial situation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023; o assess the medium-term financial viability of the GHS until 2033, assuming the legislation remains unchanged, and make recommendations on its financing; and o assess the sensitivity of the medium-term projected financial position of the GHS to changes in demographic and economic environments, as well as changes in GHS-specific assumptions. Communication of the results of actuarial valuations is very important to the HIO, enabling it to transmit a faithful picture of the financial position of the GHS and build members’ trust, which has a direct impact on the solid financial and social sustainability of the GHS. Finally, the present actuarial valuation has been undertaken in compliance with relevant international standards of actuarial practice, as promulgated by the International Actuarial Association (IAA) as well as the ISSA-ILO Guidelines on actuarial work for social security, thus aiming towards attaining the highest level of quality and transparency in actuarial practice for social security healthcare. The recommendations formulated therein are also in conformity with the relevant social security standards of the ILO. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 2 1.2. Scope of the report The present report is structured as follows: ● Chapter 2 gives an overview of the provisions of the GHS. ● Chapter 3 describes the methodologies used to project the income and expenditure of the GHS as well as relevant financial sustainability indicators. ● Chapter 4 presents the demographic, economic and labour market framework of the actuarial valuation. ● Chapter 5 shows the past experience of the GHS and the assumptions made for the future based on that observed past experience. ● Chapter 6 presents the GHS projection results under the base scenario. ● Chapter 7 presents the reconciliation of the results with those presented in the previous actuarial valuation. ● Chapter 8 presents sensitivity scenarios and tests, which assess the sensitivity of base scenario projection results to future changes in the demographic and economic environments, as well as changes in GHS-specific assumptions. ● Chapter 9 presents the conclusions and recommendations. ● Chapter 10 presents the actuarial opinion of the present valuation. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 3 2. Description of the General Healthcare System provisions This chapter gives an overview of the GHS provisions. A more complete description is provided in Annex 1. 2.1. Covered population The GHS covers the following categories of beneficiaries: ● Citizens of the Republic of Cyprus who have their ordinary residence in the areas controlled by the Government of the Republic of Cyprus. ● European Union citizens who have their ordinary residence and either work or have acquired the right of permanent residence in the Republic of Cyprus. ● Third-country citizens who have their ordinary residence in the Republic of Cyprus and have acquired legally either the right of permanent residence or the right to equal treatment in the sectors of social insurance, according to the provisions of the Cyprus National Law. ● Other categories (such as refugees) under certain conditions. ● Persons who are family members of the first two points or persons who are family members of the third point and who have also acquired legally the right of permanent residence. Family members are the spouse of the beneficiary and the children under the age of 21, or over the age of 21 who are dependent on them or their spouse, as determined by Regulations. 2.2. Healthcare services under GHS All beneficiaries have access to the same healthcare services covered by the GHS. The healthcare services covered are described in table 2.1. Table 2.1. Healthcare services covered by GHS by implementation date Date implemented Healthcare service 1 June 2019 Personal doctors for adults and children Specialist doctors for outpatient care Pharmacies and pharmaceuticals for outpatient care (Phase I Drugs: Generics/Off Patent and MeToo) Laboratories for outpatient care 1 June 2020 Inpatient care 1 September 2020 Accident and emergency care, ambulance services and Phase II Drugs (Innovative/high-cost Drugs) 1 December 2020 Dentists for preventive dental care Nurses and allied health professionals: physiotherapists, clinical psychologists, clinical dieticians, speech therapists, occupational therapists for outpatient care 1 October 2021 Midwives 1 January 2022 Palliative care 1 January 2023 Institutional rehabilitation services 1 November 2023 Allied health professionals: podologists for outpatient care Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 4 2.3. Financing approach For the implementation of the GHS, a GHS Fund has been established for the purpose of gathering the relevant contributions, and from which all payments to providers of healthcare services are made. The GHS Fund is administered by the Health Insurance Organization (HIO). The HIO sets an individual global budget for each segment of healthcare following consultations with the respective representatives of the healthcare providers. The total global budget corresponds to the annual expenditure for healthcare services covered by the GHS. In any given financial year, the actual expenditure for any segment of healthcare within the framework of the GHS cannot exceed the predetermined global budget, irrespective of the volume of services provided. This practice aims at containing the cost and ensuring the sustainability of the scheme. The annual global budget of each healthcare segment is allocated to the 12 months of the calendar year. 2.4. Source of funding The GHS Fund revenues come from contributions, co-payments, personal contributions (contribution I)2, donations and legacies, investment income from assets of the HIO and any other income accrued from the activities of the HIO. The main GHS source of financing is contributions. 2.5. Reimbursement methods The HIO reimburses providers through various reimbursement methods; these are: 1. Price list (fixed fee): Reimbursement is calculated based on the list price of each item for the specific date. 2. Point system: Reimbursement is calculated based on the number of points of each activity in a group, the total claimed number of points per group and the group budget of each month. Point values are calculated monthly, based on the monthly budget and the total number of points for the specific month. The HIO can define minimum or maximum amounts for point values. Claims reimbursements are based on the calculated point value of the specific group. 3. Capitation reimbursement: Reimbursement is not claim-based. It concerns the personal doctors and the services they offer to beneficiaries registered in their list. It is calculated based on the number of days each beneficiary is registered to a personal doctor list according to a daily rate corresponding to the age group of the beneficiary. 4. Performance reimbursement: Implemented in 2022 and aiming at improving quality of services. The reimbursement amount for each provider is calculated based on various key performance indicators (KPIs). 5. Inpatient diagnosis related group (DRG) point system reimbursement: Inpatient services are reimbursed per case based on a DRG reimbursement method. The DRG cases are separated into normal, specialised and births. The Standard Base Rates (point value) which apply for each hospital for normal and specialised cases, are determined based on the score of each hospital on specific qualitative criteria. The Standard Base Rates for specialised cases are higher than the Standard Base Rates for normal cases. The Base Rate for all birth cases is fixed and it is the same for all hospitals. A pre-agreed number of points is defined for each hospital for normal and for specialised cases, up to which no discount factors apply on each hospital’s respective Standard ______ 2 Personal Contribution I will be paid in case a beneficiary goes directly to an outpatient specialist without a referral. Some exemptions are applied, as per section A1.5.2 of Annex 1. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 5 Base Rates. In case a hospital exceeds its pre-agreed number of points, discount factors apply in order not to exceed the global budget. 6. Fixed annual amount: A&E Department for public hospitals and ambulances of public hospitals. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 6 3. Projection methodologies The present actuarial valuation of the GHS involves cash-flow projections of its revenue and expenditures over a medium term, until 2033, so as to be able to estimate changes in the reserve. These changes vary from one year to the next as a function of the difference between the GHS revenue and expenditures. The actuarial projections in this report are based on: (i) the current legal provisions and governance of the GHS, such as eligible beneficiary population, healthcare services covered, financing approach and reimbursement methods; (ii) data regarding the starting point of the projections including data on the GHS contributors and registered beneficiaries; (iii) actual past experience and trends in the GHS contributory income and expenditure of each GHS healthcare service; and (iv) assumptions regarding future demographic and economic experience, as well as scheme-specific assumptions such as utilization rates and unit costs. Figure 3.1 shows graphically the methodological modelling framework used in this actuarial valuation. Details of that modelling framework are provided in Annex 2. Figure 3.1. Actuarial methodological modelling framework It follows from figure 3.1 that the actuarial methodological modelling framework has the following four components: 1. The demographic, labour market and macroeconomic component that provides a projection of the population, labour force, employment levels and macroeconomic data that are needed as input for the modelling of the GHS expenditure and revenues. 2. The GHS income component that calculates GHS contribution income, other GHS income and other items treated as GHS income as described in section 3.1. GHS contribution income is calculated by projecting the assessment base for contributions, resulting from working income of the employed population and pension income of the pensioner population, using the economic and demographic data supplied by the above component together with scheme-specific assumptions, including the coverage of the contributing employed population. 3. The GHS expenditure component that projects expenditure in various GHS healthcare services, on the basis of the projection of the eligible beneficiary population and scheme-specific assumptions of future utilization and cost developments, as well as GHS administrative expenditure. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 7 4. The GHS financial results component that calculates the annual balance of GHS income and expenditure and produces the indicators used for assessing the GHS financial sustainability, as well as determining the adequacy of current contribution rates. 3.1. Methodology for modelling GHS income The revenue of the GHS includes contribution income, other income and other items treated as income. The GHS contribution income, which represents the largest share of GHS income, results from working income of the employed population and pension income of the pensioner population. In particular, it is based on the following sources of income: ● Earnings of employees: salaried and self-employed persons. Employed and self-employed persons are the General Social Insurance Scheme (GSIS) contributors. ● GSIS pensions. ● Other pensions, such as Government Employees Pension Scheme (GEPS) and Social Pension Scheme (SPS). Other GHS income includes revenues from rental income, interest on cash deposits, dividends of shares, other investment income sources, other taxable income related to GHS as well as EU pensioners’ and tourists’ medical expenses, all of which are of lesser financial importance. Other items treated as GHS income include co-payments, personal contribution I (see Annex 1) and discounts/clawbacks from pharmaceutical companies. For each year in the projection period 2024–2033, the GHS contribution income (CI) for each source of contributory income is projected by multiplying the legislated contribution rate (CR) by the size of the contributing population and its corresponding assessment base for the payment of contributions. The assessment base is the total amount of income subject to contributions. CIt = CRt * Contributing Populationt * Assessment Baset The total GHS contribution income (CI) of all sources of income is the summation of each income source’s CI. The legislated contribution rate (CR) of each source of income is presented in table 3.1. Table 3.1. Legislated contribution rates (percentages) Source of Income Contributor Total Individual Employer State Employed Salaried employees 2.65 2.90 4.70 10.25 Self-employed 4.00 – 4.70 8.70 Pensioners GSIS, GEPS, other 2.65 – 4.70 7.35 Other income Rent, interest, dividends, other 2.65 – – 2.65 The contributing population consists of the employed population, salaried and self-employed persons, as well as the pensioner population. The assessment base represents the total amount of earnings of employed persons and the total amount of pension income of the pensioner population, which are subject to contribution payments. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 8 Figure 3.2 presents the methodological modelling approach used for calculating the GHS contribution income, resulting from GSIS insurable earnings of employed persons and GSIS pension income of the pensioner population, using the ILO actuarial pension model, which is currently used for actuarial valuation purposes of the GSIS. Figure 3.2. Methodology: GHS contribution income from GSIS income sources Figure 3.3 presents the methodology used for calculating the GHS income from the GSIS active insured population, while figure 3.4 presents the methodology used for calculating the GHS income from the GSIS pensioner population. Figure 3.3. Methodology regarding GHS income from GSIS contributing population Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 9 As shown in figure 3.3, the demographic projections of the active insured population are derived from the following: ● The total population is projected starting with the actual population by age and gender, and projecting that population over the next decade using appropriate assumptions concerning fertility, mortality and migration. ● Labour force participation rates are applied to the total population to obtain the labour force, distributed by age and gender. ● The labour force is then separated into employed and unemployed persons. ● Finally, GHS active contributors, which in essence are the GSIS active contributors, are projected by using appropriate assumptions about the rate of coverage of the employed population under the GSIS and annual decrements of termination causes under the cohort method. Figure 3.4. Methodology regarding GHS income from the GSIS pensioner population As illustrated in figure 3.4, in order to determine the projected number of GSIS pensioners, by type of pension, the following income development process is applied: ● Starting with the number of active insured persons and using past service records, it is determined whether these persons are eligible for the various types of pensions. ● Once this potential population of beneficiaries is established, a probability of occurrence of the risk involved (type of benefit) is applied to the eligible population in order to determine the number of new pensioners that will emerge each year. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 10 The probability of occurrence of the benefit varies according to the benefit involved. It may be: o retirement rates for determining statutory pensions; o invalidity incidence rate for determining invalidity pensions; and o mortality rates for determining survivors’ pensions. These new GSIS pensioners are then projected into the future using survival rates. The GHS income resulting from pension income other than the GSIS is projected by multiplying the projected total pension amount for each source, such as the GEPS and SPS, by the relevant contribution rate, using pension models other than ILO models. The GHS income resulting from other income is projected by multiplying the projected income from each of the above sources by the corresponding legislated contribution rate. The GHS investment income is projected by multiplying each year the GHS Fund accumulated surplus by the corresponding year’s interest rate. Finally, the GHS income resulting from other items treated as income for co-payments and contribution I is projected by multiplying the projected utilization with the corresponding co-payment and contribution I amounts. Discounts and clawbacks from pharmaceutical companies are projected based on the development of expenditure on pharmaceuticals. 3.2. Methodology for modelling the GHS expenditure The expenditure of the GHS consists of the benefit expenditure and administrative costs. The benefit expenditure represents the largest share of GHS expenditure, while administration cost is only tiny fraction of total GHS expenditure. The projection of future benefit expenditure implies the estimation of the covered beneficiary population, which is different from the contributing population. The covered beneficiary population includes all persons who are entitled to benefits, who according to the GHS legislation also includes people who do not contribute, such as covered dependants and other inactive people such as the unemployed. For each year in the projection period 2024–2033, the benefits expenditure (BE) for each healthcare service is projected by multiplying the covered beneficiary population (CovPop), i.e., the number of potential beneficiaries, by a utilization rate and the average unit cost. BEt = CovPopt * Utilization ratet * Average Unit Costt The total benefit expenditure of all GHS healthcare services is the summation of each healthcare service BE. Utilization ratet is the number of invoices per capita (1 in case of capitation reimbursement). Average Unit Costt is the average cost weight (average number of points) multiplied by the average point value. Administrative expenditure consists of staff costs and non-staff costs and is projected using factors which reflect wages and prices respectively. Report to the HIO: Actuarial valuation of the GHS as of 31 December 2023, covering the period 2024–2033 11 3.2.1. GHS healthcare ser